Headlines
Preacher Review
Is It The Time Of The Preacher?
♦Tripwire’s Senior Editor Andrew Colman grabs his crucifix and his holy water and takes a look at the first episode of AMC’s Preacher, adapting Vertigo’s hit series created by Garth Ennis and Steve Dillon…
Preacher Episode One
Directors: Evan Goldberg, Seth Rogen
Stars: Dominic Cooper, Joseph Gilgun, Ruth Negga
Just like Watchmen before it, Preacher was an immensely popular series within comic fandom that had a lot of issues preventing it from making the jump to celluloid or television – indeed, as with Moore and Gibbons’ 12 parter, many thought its take on religion would never work with American audiences. Garth Ennis and Steve Dillon’s original series, which ran from 1995 to 2000, was an offshoot of sorts from their previous collaboration, Hellblazer. Unlike its predecessor, whose mise en scene was the benighted London of The Pogues and The Clash, Preacher was a less lyrical, more bawdy romp set in a mythical West which nevertheless was underpinned by mischievous, irreverent and often subversive satire. As with Hellblazer it relied on compulsive storytelling shot through with graphic violence and gallows humour – although obviously this was less familiar territory for the creators. After almost two decades of the property being bounced from studio to studio, many of whom were wary of the comic’s controversial nature, it finally landed late last year with AMC, who quickly assembled the cast and crew, ordering ten episodes, no doubt to capitalize further on the phenomenal success of their Walking Dead franchise.
Goldberg, Catlin and Seth Rogen’s pilot for the series is a better effort than Constantine, which neutered the spirit of Hellblazer – but it does seem rushed, sloppy and far too keen to throw the viewer in at the deep end. Although the languid opening montage is cinematic, hinting at a more stylized, challenging take on the comic series, it descends into familiar, if somewhat half-baked territory, with many of the characters seemingly on auto-pilot. Dominic Cooper’s Jesse Custer, the eponymous preacher of a rural Texas backwater, lacks the feral intensity, menace and charisma of the comic version, while Ruth Negga is game as Cassidy’s girlfriend Tulip, but doesn’t exude the vulnerability of her four colour counterpart. Joe Gilgun’s effort as the libertine vampire Cassidy, however, does evoke the spirit of Ennis and Dillon’s work, his unapologetically amoral earthiness a solid and knowing portrayal, but then it is as plum and easy a role as an actor could hope for.
Although the pilot of any new series has to kick things quickly into gear, the producers do seem too keen to squeeze an extensive ensemble cast into its 65 minutes, while attempting to find the motivation of the leads, and what makes them tick – especially of course Jesse Custer. It might’ve been wiser to start off everything with less sturm und drang, whilst bringing in some supporting characters in later episodes – the showrunners anxious to lay on the show’s remit with a trowel. Custer’s wrestling with his conscience jars with the comic version, and he seems all too happy to break cover once the town bully focuses his attention on him. The tone and setting (the program was shot in and around Albuquerque) seem a little too pat, the cast more caricatured than necessary. There are exceptions, such as the stoic and loyal Emily Woodrow (Lucy Griffiths), Custer’s girl Friday, but she does seem to have wandered in from another show.
As for the plot development, all we really learn in this instalment is that a mysterious supernatural force has swept across the planet, attacking church leaders and congregations in various countries. Eventually it alights at Jesse’s church, rendering him unconscious for several days, but not (as in the comic) destroying anything. Once he’s recovered, he realizes what power he’s been imbued with. The rest of the show consists of Custer parrying away the needs of his flakey flock, spliced with the introduction of Tulip and Cassidy, both featuring plenty of sub-Tarantino violence and slaughter (all three leads are remarkably adept at hand to hand combat). Plus there’s Sheriff Root (W. Earl Brown, oddly too sympathetic) and his son Arseface (Ian Colletti) already in attendance.
The series opener is undermined by the need to follow convention and ensure that nothing gets too left-field, despite all that the source material has to offer. Gratuitous violence (this is Seth Rogen, after all) is of course on the menu, but dark, seditious satire and a more artistic undertow will have to be set aside – this is genre, rather than an inversion of a genre, which is what Ennis and Dillon’s 75 issue tour de force was. If anything, the comic series took the mythology of the cinematic Old (and current) West and made it its own. It’s a tall order for the TV series to do the same, but as it is early days for this show, and with enough onscreen for the viewer to keep watching, it may well find its feet. We await the arrival of Starr and the Saint Of Killers.
ANDREW COLMAN



You must be logged in to post a comment Login