Headlines
Ben Wheatley’s Free Fire Reviewed
All Fired Up Over Nothing
♦ Tripwire Contributing Writer JAMES DC reviews Ben Wheatley’s Free Fire, out now on Blu Ray and DVD…
Stars: Brie Larson, Armie Hammer, Sam Riley, Cillian Murphy, Michael Smiley, Sharlto Copley
Out now on DVD/Blu-ray
The very slim story goes thus: it’s the late 1970s and a couple of IRA members, Chris (Cillian Murphy) and Frank (Michael Smiley), are in Boston to buy a cache of assault rifles, machine guns and other armaments from a bunch of American criminals. They liaise with a number of underworld movers and shakers and the gun-runner himself, Vernon (Sharlto Copley). All are men, apart from one female intermediary, Justine (Brie Larson). After decamping to a deserted warehouse to seal the deal, an argument suddenly erupts between two members of the opposing sides and one fires a shot, causing some of the others to start firing, too. Everyone scatters instantly, taking shelter behind the detritus and old machinery of the ruined factory. A few guys try to negotiate a truce, but the more volatile gang members keep firing off rounds until the scene becomes a veritable bullet-fest and everyone ends up fighting for their lives. Various loyalties and friendships are tested and a psychological power play of distrust, cruelty and one-upmanship results, as a random element of two hired assassins invade the melee, too. As the members of each group gradually succumb to multiple wounds – albeit whilst engaging in badinage and taunting the enemy, ‘over the barricades’, at opportune moments – we are left wondering who will manage to survive the massacre, as Chris and Justine vie for the endgame in order to escape, barely alive.
According to Wheatley (in the sparse ‘extras’ interview features on the DVD of Free Fire) he wanted, in part, to create a more pared down and gritty crime-thriller than the usual fare; set mostly in one place and with a limited amount of protagonists undergoing ‘real-time’ traumas, so as to portray a more involving and ‘realistic’ jeopardy story. At first, this novel premise sets the film on a promising track. However, the concept soon runs out of steam, rapidly becoming repetitive and, more damagingly, unbelievable – precisely what the director purportedly wanted to avoid. For one thing, the sight of people with bleeding, painful wounds dragging themselves around the floor for hours on end, whilst constantly hurling provocative insults at the enemy or incongruously joshing with one another, hardly seems ‘realistic’. Most of the dialogue, as well as much of the behaviour, comes across as highly unlikely within the supposedly realistic setting.
“At first, this novel premise sets the film on a promising track. However, the concept soon runs out of steam, rapidly becoming repetitive and, more damagingly, unbelievable – precisely what the director purportedly wanted to avoid.”
In terms of influences, it is apparent that Wheatley is attempting, in a pick ‘n’ mix way, to pay homage to a roster of gritty and muscular ’60s and ’70s crime epics by the likes of Martin Scorsese (one of Free Fire’s executive producers, in fact), Sidney Lumet, William Friedkin, Sam Peckinpah, and later Postmodern directors like John Woo and the aforementioned Tarantino. Plus the whole Blaxploitation genre and a hundred other ‘retro-hip’, hard-and-fast films of years gone by. But he ultimately fails to bring off such a feat, perhaps too slavishly in awe of such filmmakers, while not enough of a visionary to pull off something truly radical.
It’s a shame, because I can see the germ of a thrilling, unique film here, a type of violent ‘chamber piece’, revolving around stuck rats in a trap, after a dodgy deal goes wrong. Instead of the preponderance of modish ’70s apparel, showy pyrotechnics and trendy cinematic references – as well as the obligatory ultra-hip, ironic soundtrack by the likes of John Denver and Creedence Clearwater Revival – this could have been, say, a brutal but droll absurdist drama, with echoes of Samuel Beckett. Rather, it feels like a misjudged attempt to make a cult-indie version of an episode of The Sweeney, albeit with lashings of ultra-violence, a surfeit of shallow and unlikable characters, and set in a deserted Boston warehouse instead of a run-down pub, in West Ham. So why exactly was Free Fire set in the 1970s? What relevance does that decade have on any of this? Surely the basic scenario could have just as easily been set in modern times? Well, as I say, like Tarantino and all other cine-geek directors, Wheatley loves to play around with the décor, clothes, outdated attitudes, ribald humour and cinematic tics of that far-flung decade – no problem there, per se, as long as he were to actually accomplish such a task. But the main reason is that if modern technology, like mobile phones, were part of the story, the film would be over within about 20 minutes; the protagonists would instantly call for help and the cavalry would rapidly arrive to blow the enemy away (Wheatley confesses to such a ruse in the ‘extras’ interview, but I had already instinctively figured it out, as I watched the film).
Another major fault with the script is that we don’t end up caring about any of these A-holes; there are hardly any interesting or sympathetic characters, with the absence of a decent backstory for any of them compounding the problem. (One of the better characters, played by Brie Larson as the only woman in the ensemble, should have been more fleshed out, for a start.) Furthermore, there aren’t enough establishing shots near the start in order to let us settle in a bit, before all hell is let loose; thus the impact of the gun battle is diminished through lack of context. Of course, opponents of this viewpoint will say that Wheatley is simply going for a ‘jump in the deep end’, minimalistic structure, where it doesn’t necessarily matter that we don’t know anything about these people before the disaster strikes – they are suddenly put in danger, out of the blue, like any of us potentially could be, and that’s enough to carry the film. Sure, such a conceit has worked well in many films, over the years. However, most of those films gradually made us empathise, in some way, with the humans on screen. Wheatley’s film doesn’t bother with any of that. He thinks a barrage of meaningless, smart alec one-liners and a few grunts and moans while these psychos endlessly duck and hide from oncoming bullets will suffice to make us care. It doesn’t.
So then, what is left? Not much, really. There are a few nice, slightly balletic touches to the all-in-one, action set piece – although, having said that, I have seen more exciting and inventively choreographed ‘bullet fights’ in Hollywood B-Westerns from the 1940s! But, to make matters worse, as the violence, gunfire and multiple wounds ratchet up, everything becomes more hectic in terms of three-dimensional ‘spatial awareness’, i.e. many situations are hindered by an extremely confusing mise-en-scene. For a lot of the running time, you simply cannot make out who is shooting who; like a lot of modern filmmakers, Wheatley doesn’t seem to understand the basics of how to tell a story well in cinematic terms, instead opting for a ‘blipvert’ aesthetic and visual free-for-all, all the while hoping that no one will notice (and no, just because the gun battle is a tumult doesn’t mean that the film itself should be incomprehensible in those particular scenes, also).
Sure, I will concede that, despite the increasingly tiresome proceedings, there is the occasional funny crack or pratfall, plus a couple of mildly absorbing scenes where we – sort of – root for one of the dodgy guttersnipes trying to survive. And there is always the pleasure of watching riveting and endearing actors like Michael Smiley and Sharlto Copley. But then, because of this, one wishes that Wheatley and Jump had excised some of the blander, more disposable characters in order to concentrate on these more well-rounded, intriguing ones; ironically, given his intentions, Wheatley was not minimalistic enough, this time round.
In the final reckoning, this is a one-dimensional, uninspired and rather tedious folly, lacking any real depth or innovation. But let’s hope that Wheatley eventually gets his act together and recaptures some of the imagination and ingenuity he showed in his earlier work. You never know….



You must be logged in to post a comment Login