Frank Miller - Push the Wall
Frank Miller - Push the Wall

Doctor Who

Our Man In Los Angeles Reviews The Doctor Who Christmas Special

Published

on

The Ultimate Time Share

Tripwire’s man in Los Angeles Robert Cave takes a look at the Doctor Who Christmas Special, Joy To The World, which was shown on BBC1 and Disney Plus on Christmas Day…

Joy to the World
By Steven Moffat
Directed by Alex Sanjiv Pillai

Well, that one wasn’t as straightforward as it might have been, but I did come to this episode jet lagged and slightly the worse for the season. On the Third rewatch the next morning everything flowed together much better. Like Christmas itself, there can be a massive extra weight of expectation that comes with festive episodes, especially when they have, as in the case of Doctor Who, become an institution in and of themselves.

A Christmas Doctor Who story has to play more broadly than a standard episode. It needs to carry the whole extended family, including those uncles, cousins and grandparents who don’t actually watch the show with any great regularity or passion. Like the BBC itself, there is a certain cultural misty-eyed nostalgia for the idea of Doctor Who, and that goes a long way, particularly at a time of year where half forgotten traditions are repeated as they are just an accepted part of “what we do.” The weight of expectation can really crush a story before a single script idea has been typed.

Fortunately, Steven Moffat, back on writing duties for his first Christmas episode since the end of his run as show runner, is a skilled artisan at crafting exactly this kind of story. And he’s been away long enough to have recharged his creative batteries from the kind of burn-out that can come from doing any job after a while.

He’s got a new idea, and it is pretty great: The Time Hotel. It’s the ultimate time share; when unrealised temporal assets, empty rooms in hotels, can be sold on to time travellers playing dress up in chronistically appropriate costumes. Brilliant. There is even a brief nod to to the classic UK children’s TV Series Mr Benn, in which the titular bowler-hatted adventurer went on a similar series of dress-up adventures throughout time and space.

There isn’t much in the way of a villain, unless you count the arms manufacturers for Villengard, the unacceptable face of capitalism in the Whoniverse. But their mundanity of evil lacks even a personification. Villengard’s weaponized MacGuffin is the “star seed”, an AI baby star that can possess (and destroy) lifeforms as it seeks to deploy itself for maximum carnage. But the star seed needs time to grow, hence its search for a means of time travel so that it can cook itself in the past and be readily deployed for the present…

Coming back to expectations, in our modern multi-channel streaming entertainment world, where there are an ever-increasing crush of audience attention. Casting decisions are made and announced months in advance and leveraged as part of the promotional effort to get folk to actually sit down and watch a hour of TV. Under such circumstances it is hard to pull off a surprises – but this episode really managed to deliver something unexpected with a quasi-secondary companion in the form of Steph de Whalley playing hotel manager Anita Benn.

De Whalley’s performance is pitched perfectly as Anita gives Ncuti Gatwa’s Doctor a lesson in sequential living as he waits a year to catch up with his own timey-wimey bootstrap solution to a literal ticking time bomb. It is a testament to Director Alex Sanjiv Pillai that he really he makes the repetition of the Doctor meeting himself so compelling that you almost forget what is going to happen next when the do meet up for the second time.

Anita’s reward for her part keeping the Doctor company in and around Joy’s room over the course of a year is… a job at the Time Hotel. This struck me as a little unfair, I would even go so far as to call it a swizz. It is probably a curse of Doctor Who fandom that we never met an interesting supporting character we don’t want to see again, and I am sure I would not be alone in wanting to see Anita take at least one spin in the TARDIS, if not a whole season of Big Finish adventures.

Don’t get me wrong. For all I loved Anita, the casting and announcement of Bridgerton and Derry Girls star Nicola Coughlan as the episode’s overt companion Joy Almondo was a marketing coup. Doctor Who is lucky to have her. I just was not expecting her to ultimately have such limited screen time.

She does get the episode’s best lines, righteous fury expressed not nearly directly enough the (UK) government’s downright inhumanity during the Covid years. She has agency; first taking custody of the star seed suitcase, and then later choosing to accept that seed into her body and become a star, moving its destructive force away from the Earth and effectively negating it as a weapon.

Like I say, I’ve watched this episode three and a half times so far. It is a fun episode, one that I already want to watch again. The few gripes I have, mainly about the vicious bodycount of suitcase couriers, including Joy, and Joel Fry’s Trev, two other Time Hotel employees and one unnamed guest, are small and are addressed within the narrative in a way that explains but isn’t quite satisfactory. Likewise there is a problem with Joy’s agency. She is possessed by the star seed, the Doctor breaks that control, but she later decides “of her own free will” to just accept transfiguration into a star that brings not just the titular Joy to the World, but a sense of hope too. The script emphasises it IS her choice, but there is enough space for audience doubt too, especially as Joy is not shown to have any other family or friends. Is this story meant to be the anti-It’s a Wonderful Life? A tale in which Joy’s death actually improves things? I thing it is a plausible reading, and one I don’t necessarily dislike. I just could have done without the clumsy star of Bethlehem moment, which struck me as a little too on the nose.

Still, I enjoyed it, and am now excited for the second full season of the Disney era. More episodes please. And, based on what we have seen so far, I’d like to see the Disney/BBC partnership to carry on long into the future. I’ll see you then.